Articles

Articles

Latest News

As part of our service at Harris Tate, we produce a range of legal articles that are published in various media, designed to alert our clients to legal developments that may affect them.

Our legal articles are written by lawyers and legal executives and discuss legal aspects relating to industries, businesses and individuals as well as focusing on everyday legal topics of interest.  These articles provide information to help educate our clients on different topics and current events in the law.  They may raise additional questions.  Please do not hesitate to contact us with your questions or to discuss your individual situation in more detail.

Counting down to a major overhaul of Trust Law

11 December 2019

Following a process that has taken almost two decades, the Trusts Act 2019 (“Act”) received royal assent on 30 July 2019, and will come into force on 30 January 2021. The new Act will replace the out-of-date Trustee Act 1956 (and the Perpetuities Act 1964) and will codify and simplify fundamental trustee obligations and trust principles. This article summarises some of the notable changes.

1. Disclosure requirements

One potentially tricky area for trustees has been the extent to which information is disclosed to beneficiaries.  The Act follows a similar approach to guidance recently provided by the New Zealand Supreme Court which favours keeping the beneficiaries informed. It imposes two positive presumptions on the trustees – firstly, to notify beneficiaries that they are actually a beneficiary and provide them with basic trust information and secondly, to provide trust information upon the request of a beneficiary - unless the trustees can reasonably and legitimately decide not to provide the information. The range of information that a beneficiary can request is defined widely and there will no doubt be an influx of requests for information from beneficiaries. Trustees will need to consider very carefully, and perhaps take professional advice, as to whether there are circumstances which mean the trustees can reasonably refuse to provide certain information. 

2. Trustee Duties

A significant change is the setting out of trustee ‘standard duties’ which are separated into ‘mandatory duties’ and ‘default duties’. While a trust deed cannot exclude or modify the ‘mandatory duties’, the ‘default duties’ may be overridden.  Where trust deeds are drafted to modify or exclude default duties, trust advisers will now be required to ensure the settlor of the trust is aware of the effect of any such modifications and exclusions. 

The mandatory trustee duties set out in the Act are:

  • Know the terms of the trust
  • Act in accordance with the terms of the trust
  • Act honestly and in good faith.
  • Act for the benefit of the beneficiaries or to further the purpose of the trust
  • Exercise power for proper purpose

 

The default trustee duties are: 

  • A duty of general duty of care
  • A duty to invest prudently
  • A duty not to exercise power for own benefit
  • A duty to consider exercise of power
  • A duty not to bind or commit trustees to the future exercise of a discretion
  • A duty to avoid any conflict of interest
  • A duty of impartiality
  • A duty not to profit from the trusteeship of a trust
  • A duty to act for no reward 
  • A duty to act unanimously

The Act also provides an overarching guidance that trustees, in performance of their duties, need to have regard to the context and objectives of the trust. Trustees will need to ensure that trust deeds clearly set out the objectives of the trust in order to avoid any future difficulties in exercising their duties and consider whether any of the default trustee duties should be “carved out” in order to achieve those objectives. 

3. Safekeeping of trust documents

The Act provides that it is mandatory for the trustees (or at least one of them) to retain copies of the core trust documents for the entire duration of their trusteeships.  The suite of core documents include, but are not limited to, the trust deed, variations to trust deed, memorandum of wishes, documents for appointment, removal and discharge of trustees, trustee resolutions and written contracts and accounting records. It would be wise for trustees to start compiling relevant documents now. 

4. Trustee powers: 

The new Act also confers upon the trustees “all powers” necessary to manage and carry out the trust (which is in line with current market practice of including “all powers” provisions in trust deeds). We would still recommend that future trust deeds contain express powers to for example buy, sell, give security, mortgage and give guarantees to satisfy the requirements of financial institutions.

In terms of trustees’ powers of investment, the new Act contains a list of factors that a trustee may consider in exercising their power to invest (as did the Trustee Act 1956). The duty to invest prudently is one of the default duties that could be modified or excluded.  Trustees will also have a broad power to determine whether return on investment is to be treated as income or capital (for the purposes of distributions and preparing financial statements), and to apportion receipts or outgoings to or from income or capital. 

5. Life of a Trust

The maximum life of a trust established after 30 January 2021 will 125 years (compared to the limit of 80 years under the old legislation).  In some cases it may be possible to resettle an existing trust on to a new trust provided that resettled trust has a maximum duration of no more than 125 years from when the original trust was established.

6. Delegation of trustee powers

The new Act clarifies and widens the range of circumstances where a trustee can delegate their duties by way of power of attorney.  These circumstances include absence from New Zealand plus temporary inability to be contacted, physical incapability, and temporary lack of capacity. Other than under the prescribed circumstances, the trustees must not delegate certain fundamental powers such as power to appoint trustees, and/or power to resettle. 

7. Restrictions on trustee exemption/indemnity clause:

Independent trustees would have been very familiar with trustee liability/indemnity clauses in the trust deeds. The Act restricts the use of trustee exemption/indemnity clauses to the extent that such clauses are not to limit a trustee’s liability for breach of trust arising from dishonesty or willful misconduct, and gross negligence. This serves as a reminder that all trustees need be vigilant in their exercise of trustee duties. The essence of a trust is that trustees have a fiduciary duty to, and, are accountable to, the beneficiaries. If a trust deed contains provisions that exclude all possible liabilities of the trustees, then it will not be enforceable under the Act. 

8. What do you need to do? 

As innocuous as some of the changes may appear, the first step would be to review existing trust deeds.  Trustees will need to consider carefully the applicability of the Act and ascertain whether variations will be desirable (if the terms of the trust deed allow for variations).

But wait there’s more

Whilst as much a tax and accounting issue, Trustees need to note that as part of amendments to the Income Tax Act 2007, from 1 April 2020, a beneficiary of a trust, may be deemed a ‘settlor’ for income tax purpose if the trust owes the beneficiary more than $25,000 and no interest is paid on the amount owing at the prescribed interest rate in the income year. As many trusts have loan and/or current accounts the change in tax law, trustees and settlors should seek legal and accounting advice as to the implications and how to best address the imminent change.

By Grant Harris. Managing Director of Harris Tate Limited and a Tauranga Property Investors Association Committee Member